When is bulk fermentation done?

shaping dough
Under- or overproofed?

It can be difficult for a cottage baker to figure out when bulk fermentation has proceeded enough for the dough to be released from its fermentation vessel onto the counter for shaping. Fermentation − the activities of yeast and lactic bacteria producing volume and flavors, respectively − continues past the stage of bulk fermentation and shaping and into the early stage of cold retardation in the refrigerator overnight. That is where and when fermentation eventually comes to a halt.

The point of interrupting the resting phase of bulk fermentation after several hours is:

  • the need to prevent the microorganisms from entirely exhausting their food supply before cold retardation in the refrigerator overnight,
  • the need to shape the dough at some time before the stage of cold retardation.

The micro-organisms need to stay active for as long as possible to produce the loaf’s rise and crumb and flavor profile, but not long enough to affect the deterioration of the gluten network.

Seek to establish and find a balance between the following factors. The overall Goldilocks balance is somewhere near the middle.

Fermentation Assessment

Fermentation Assessment

Moving the sliders according to your assessment will give you a visual clue as to the likelihood that bulk fermentation has proceeded enough for moving on to the shaping stage. The vertical Goldilocks Zone is kind of in the middle.
5
No need to move this slider.
The Goldilocks Zone for the following sliders is kind of in this middle.
77.5F
65F90F
Dough temperature is the most important variable in managing bulk fermentation. The target bulk fermentation temperature range is between 76-82F or 24-28C.
4H
0H8H
Bulk fermentation time varies also depending on the strength of the levain.
50% yes
0% yes100% yes
Some recipes or instructions aim at a volume increase of 2.5, which is really 150%. 30% to 50% is perhaps enough.
50% yes
0% yes100% yes
Risen dough still rising may have a slightly domed appearance on top.
50% yes
0% yes100% yes
Bubbles on top. If using a clear container, bubbles underneath and/or along the sides.
50% yes
0% yes100% yes
Bubbles on top. If using a clear container, bubbles underneath and/or along the sides.
Start Over

For the baker, assessing if bulk fermentation has proceeded enough to start shaping the dough is more of an art and less of a science. If most of the above-assessed factors align near the middle, I would favor moving on to the stage of shaping.

Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *